pentium wrote:
I couldn't care about USB support. PS/2 ain't gonna go out of style any time soon.
Consider this situation. I want to cluster these systems on a single keyboard + mouse and two screens:
* An Onyx2 (PS/2 + analogue)
* An Octane2 with V12 + DCD (PS/2 + 2x DVI)
* A Tezro (USB or PS/2 + 2x DVI)
* A Hackintosh PC (USB + 2x DVI)
As you can see, I've got analogue and digital screen outputs, and USB and PS/2 keyboards and mice. I don't want to dumb down the displays to analogue for the sake of that Onyx2.
This restricts me to a DVI based dual head KVM switch (DVI-I to be precise -- it must pass the analogue signal of the Onyx2).
Next issue is practical: I've never seen a KVM with DVI and PS/2 ports which supports resolutions > 1600x1200. I guess nobody bothered to make the chipset for that? And I'm pretty sure that was not a dual head either.
Dual head DVI + USB KVMs on the other hand are easy to find, I've been using them for years at work. And unlike the older VGA + PS/2 KVM's they actually *work*. Not work "most of the time, except ...", or " works except this system XYZ has issues with keyboard repeat rate", or "works except this system ABC (sometimes) needs to be rebooted after I switch inputs...", if you've ever used a PS/2 KVM you know the drill.
So that's why PS/2 is out too. I will happily sacrifice the capability to support more than a
maximum of six simultaneously depressed keys plus the modifier keys (shift, alt etc..)
in exchange for that. (that is apparently the N-key rollover limit for USB, even though apparently many keyboards have a problem with more than 3 keys due to the way their diode matrix is wired). In either case, this never bothered me. Unpredictable KVM behavior on the other hand can be immensely frustrating.
So this process of elimination leaves me with a DVI + USB based KVM, plus the need for two USB-PS/2 converters. These exist btw, although PS/2 emulator is the better term, but cost ~ $100.
The alternative is to buy monitors with 3 digital and 1 analogue input and switch video inputs at the monitors, and use an old PS/2 KVM to switch only the keyboard + mouse. This hack would be rather unpractical in day-to-day use.
On the other end of the room, I have a cluster of older systems, basically ranging from Professional IRIS to Octane1 MXE. For those I can settle for an analogue, PS/2 based KVM (and live with the occasional weirdness). Except, back on topic, the existing Indigo keyboard/mouse converter doesn't work with a KVM. I've spent hundreds of euros and tried many versions, including ones supposedly made for SGI & SUN, and it won't work. What works (mostly) is powering up e.g. an Indigo with a real keyboard and mouse, and then hotplugging the KVM into the loop. Sorry, but that's BS. Had this worked I would have bought a dozen of these things years ago and lived happily ever after.