leaknoil wrote:
kramlq wrote:
As I said on the previous page, google 'libel tourism' for examples. If you'd done that earlier you might have saved youself from making several more ill-informed posts. But you do what you want. I've made my point several times now and can't be bothered discussing it any more.
That has no relevance about what we were talking about. That is all about the wealthy, claimed terrorists, and tabloid journalism. Actually show a single case of libel involving someone talking bad about a seller. You can't. Where Paris Hilton files her latest libel suit doesn't really concern me.
Show me one case of libel decided against someone complaining about a seller in the UK on a forum. Seems simple enough for me. That is all I am asking. Go for it.
I swore I wouldn't respond anymore, but I'm now starting to believe you are not just trolling and genuinely don't understand. So one last try:
1) People here made accusatory comments. Bad comments about anybody are potentially libellous, whether they be about celebrity lifestyles, professional incompetance, terrorism, accusations of criminality etc.
2) This opens the potential for legal threats. Neko has had to deal with such threats in the past from eBay sellers, and said he would prefer not to have to do this for comments made on a forum he voluntarily funds.
3) You seem to feel that because such a case in the US would be difficult to win, that gives you the right to say what you want about who you want on here. First, that is against the rules. Secondly, a case would be much easier to win in other jurisdictions, and this is possible for comments made on the internet.
4) In many jurisidictions, to win you would have to prove comments about a seller scamming are 100% accurate. How would you do that?
Quote:
Actually show a single case of libel involving someone talking bad about a seller. You can't.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/u ... 009293.ece
Actually, libel threats concerning people talking bad about sellers in feedback led eBay to come up with this for their own site:
http://pages.ebay.co.uk/help/community/defam-form.html
Regardless of whether a libel case actually happens or not, even a threat of legal action takes time and potentially money to sort out (in this case, Nekos time and money). Keeping your opinions about sellers you've never even dealt with to yourself can eliminate these threats. But again, you do as you wish. At least now you know some facts.